SCOTUSblog » Academic Round-up

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Regarding Trayvon Martin and "Stand Your Ground"

This piece, by Wilson Huhn from the "Akron Law Cafe," which appears on the right sidebar of this blog, is the clearest commentary I have seen on why the Florida statute is wrong.

The key passage goes like this:
This is not really a criminal law. It is rather an attempt to celebrate a particular conception of "honor."  It does not carefully and dispassionately define its terms. Instead, it invokes memories and emotions; it reminds us of the sacrifices of our ancestors; it seeks to glorify violence and, in particular, the use of guns in the defense of justice. The key language contained in the statute – STAND YOUR GROUND – would be a terrific title for a war movie or a western, but it makes lousy law.
Well done.

No comments: