SCOTUSblog » Academic Round-up

Monday, April 27, 2015

"Reasonable Certainty" Kills Two Hostages

By many standards, the Obama Administration behaved decently and cautiously when it bombed the compound in Pakistan where Warren Weinstein and Giovanni Lo Porto were being held hostage in January. They conducted weeks of surveillance on the site to ensure that the men they wanted to kill were there, and that they were the only ones there.

Even after the strike, the CIA, of all organizations, were far from callous in their approach to the bombing. When they saw that six, not four bodies were removed from the building they had just wrecked, they investigated. They spent weeks "poring over drone video feeds, satellite data, electronic intercepts of cellphone conversations and informants’ reports" to analyze the evidence from the rubble, and then quizzed people on the ground about who those extra bodies belonged to. 

Once they realized they had killed two "Westerners," and that one was an American (bad) and another not (embarrassing), the Obama Administration did not cover up the ugly truth, but faced it. President Obama apologized even before anyone else called him on it. 

    Haji Mujtaba/Reuters  http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/25/world/asia/cia-qaeda-drone-strikes-warren-weinstein-giovanni-lo-porto-deaths.html


It's not despite this meritorious conduct, but because of it, that the drone program is a problem. Any time one man -- even a conscientious, intelligent, and deeply moral man like President Obama -- takes it upon himself to be prosecutor, judge, and executioner, he is likely to kill innocent people. No standard to which he can hold himself will be a sufficient protection against results as bad as these.