Why NFL Discipline is Such a Circus (Not in the Way it Wants)

The National Football League makes money by drawing attention to itself. It feeds off the gossip-girl behavior of ESPN and the morning pregame shows, and only benefits as long as there is something to talk about, even if it is salacious.

Some news items, however, are less good for the league. Junior Seau's death, probably resulting from repeated blows to the head suffered as a literal poster boy for hard hits, is one such item, and the league and its minions would prefer it not get much attention.

Also, the brutal behavior of many of its players, including Ray Rice and Greg Hardy, reflect the inherent, embarrassing violence and entitlement surrounding these very rich, poorly educated young men.

Roger Goodell is the primary problem, though. Because he runs a three-ring circus, his predilections and training lean toward the public relations gesture, the short-term image, and the political expedient. As a result of the Collective Bargaining Agreement and the league charter, however, he is also the sole dispenser of discipline on the league level, and that is a problem.

Goodell's punishment of Tom Brady is downright ridiculous. It may well be within his power, but it has more to do with his desire to show his independence from Patriots owner Robert Kraft than it does with any principles of law or fairness. It's just another embarrassment for him in a long line of recent debacles.

Goodell, like many Americans, including the current governor of Wisconsin, think that justice can be determined through popularity and politics. It cannot. Politics is a a useful thing; it allows for the peaceful distribution of power and treasure. Judges, however, should always be isolated from its operations, however, because what is just often is unpopular. Frankly, I could not care less what happens to Tom Brady of any other NFL player. The actions of the league demonstrate, however, what happens when crime and punishment are confused with politics.

NBC Should Dump Dungy -- He's a Distraction

Tony Dungy earned his fame as a football coach first, but since he retired from that job he has been treated as some kind of ethical guru by the meatheads at ESPN and the NFL Network. Dungy stood up for Michael Vick after Vick was convicted of running a dog fighting ring in which animals were brutally, viciously killed, and represented the early wave of black head coaches who had been denied equal treatment because of baseless assumptions about the connection between their ability and their color.

Now Dungy says that he would not have drafted Michael Sam, the SEC Defensive Player of the Year, because Sam came as gay before the draft and therefore would be "a distraction." To clear things up, Dungy said it was not Sam's homosexuality itself that would be a problem, but the "media attention" it would get.

Michael Sam 

(Francis Page Jr./Creative Commons) at http://www.neontommy.com/news/2014/02/why-do-you-care-if-michael-sam-gay

Media attention? 

The only reason the NFL exists is to get media attention. Tony Dungy's sole remaining employment relating to football is as a commentator on NBC. The NFL is, itself, nothing but a giant, expensive distraction. Every day is a "media circus" because the NFL makes all its money from television coverage.

If Dungy wants to avoid distractions, tell him to quit his job.