SCOTUSblog » Academic Round-up

Showing posts with label values. Show all posts
Showing posts with label values. Show all posts

Sunday, September 13, 2015

Torture and American Values

Image result for john yoo
The guy who argued that torture is perfectly legal

Last year, the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence put out its report on the use of torture by the CIA in the years after the 2001 attacks. The executive summary of the report runs more than 300 pages, not including the notes, and lays out in excruciating detail the process by which the CIA -- the Government in general -- decided to torture more than 100 people over three years, and the methods used in the torture.

I am most interested in how we decided to abandon our traditional values and our stated policies and laws to behave in such systematically depraved ways. As the Senate report makes clear, many people, even within the CIA (not the most squeamish of entities) were made physically sick by what the "special interrogators" were doing. All the way up the chain of command, CIA and White House people explained the legal and moral problems with these "enhanced" methods. FBI investigators tried to convince the CIA that torture was unnecessary and even counterproductive. So why did the program go forward?

There appear to be two basic answers. First, the Office of Legal Counsel, led by John Yoo, convinced leadership that the methods did not contravene international or US law. People in the position to decide were too cowardly to resist the argument that because we were attacked, we had the right to do whatever we wanted, and Yoo gave them bureaucratic cover. Once the Washington Post got wind of certain practices and threatened to report them, these craven, immoral government hacks panicked and went back to OLC to be reassured that they would not be held accountable for their actions. Yoo promised they would be OK.

Second, two sadistic creeps masquerading as psychologists misapplied training given them by the Air Force to act out their own sick fantasies of power. John Mitchel and Bruce Jessen had been taught how to resist certain nasty interrogation techniques in the Air Force SERE program, but used that training in the opposite way, to be nasty themselves. Mitchell, misunderstanding the consequences and applications of "learned helplessness," decided that they could be used to get information from prisoners.

Image result for bruce jessen
The two sadistic morons who conducted the CIA's torture program.

Mitchell was wrong, not just morally but factually and theoretically. That makes him an idiot as well as a sadist. That Jessen went along only means he became sidekick to a fool -- and what does that make him?

Our system, though, is supposed to prevent small-minded men like these from coming to positions of sufficient power to commit the evil they did. That's where we failed.

Sunday, August 30, 2015

Sound Familiar?

As long as we are on the subject, does this remind you of anyone?

He has no record of public service, but wants to gain the most powerful position in the country. He gains in popularity by tapping into the anger and resentment of an ethnic population that feels recently dispossessed of its cultural birthrights. He calls for the exclusion and prosecution of ethnic minorities within his country. His rhetoric emphasizes a patriotism of collective past greatness, and the need to return to that greatness. He has no particular policy proposals that make any sense, just grandiose and impractical declarations. He says that the system needs an outsider to tear it down and star again. The politicians around him are so embarrassed by his stridency and the notoriety it brings that they will not stand up to him and call him out for his practices.

Image result for trump      Image result for hitler

Now, I know I will raise the ire of a whole lot of people by making this comparison, but it's time to shake off the political correctness Trump and his followers so detest and call things as  they are.

So far, only because Trump has gained no power, he has done no serious damage. He probably would not and could not commit the atrocities executed by Hitler.

But Trump is following the playbook of the worst and most dangerous kind of demagogue. Taking him lightly is foolish. He needs to be put in his place by the Republican Party so we do not slip closer to the harm he could bring.

Have any doubts? I recommend to you Hannah Arendt, from Origins of Totalitarianism:

It has frequently been pointed out that totalitarian movements use and abuse democratic freedoms in order to abolish them. This is not just devilish cleverness on the part of the leaders or childish stupidity on the part of the masses. Democratic freedoms may be based on the equality of all citizens before the law; yet they acquire their meaning and function organically only where the citizens belong to and are respected by groups or form a social and political hierarchy…
            Indifference to public affairs and, neutrality on political issues, are themselves not sufficient cause for the rise of totalitarian movements. The competitive and acquisitive society of the bourgeoisie had produced apathy and even hostility toward public life not only, and not even primarily, in the social strata that were exploited and excluded from active participation in the rule of the country, but first of all in its own class…Both the early apathy and the later demand for monopolistic dictatorial direction of the nation of the nation’s foreign affairs had their roots in a way and philosophy of life so insistently and exclusively centered on the individual’s success or failure in ruthless competition that a citizen’s duties and responsibilities could be felt to be a needless drain on his limited time and energy…



Wednesday, August 5, 2015

Why Education in History is So Important


Image result for american flag background

What students learn matters.

For some people, they ought to learn certain ideas: that the United States is "exceptional," that its leaders are generally motivated by a desire to liberate the world, that its economic system of free enterprise promotes innovation and freedom, and the like. These people, many of whom protested a revision of the College Board Advanced Placement Exam in US History, understand that students' experiences in school help frame their view of the world, and they want kids to share their particular view.

To an extent, that's not only right, it's unavoidable. I want my students to believe that dictatorship causes suffering (most of the time), that freedom of expression is as productive as it is morally preferable (most of the time), that the rule of law is essential to political effectiveness.

The reaction to the AP curriculum therefore was not totally unreasonable, but it was badly skewed. There is nothing wrong, for example, with promoting the idea that Americans in the south were proud of slavery. They were. They defended the institution with the very last of their blood and treasure, and there was very limited dissent from this view of things. These facts are unfortunate and maybe even embarrassing, but they are true, and people need to understand them if they are to know US history. (They also probably need to know those facts to understand the defense of the Confederate flag and the Black Lives Matter movement.)

That the College Board could revise the test in the face of political pressure reveals the bureaucratic nature of that organization, but it also highlights the urgency of teaching kids to think for themselves, and to ask questions about the facts.

I would rather that they learn to ask: was the United States really exceptional? How? Was it exceptional in the way many leaders said it was? Is that good? Has the United States, by and large, promoted freedom in the world? How? Why? Is our economic system truly based on the market? Do we want it to be? Why?

Questions are much better than answers.

Tuesday, July 21, 2015

The Obergefell Decision is Incorrect

I think the Supreme Court decision in Obergefell v. Hodges, which declared that state prohibition of gay marriage is unconstitutional, is incorrect. I can't find a right to marry in the Constitution.

That's not to say that I think gay couples should not be married. Every state in the union, and the federal government as well, should endorse and protect same-sex marriages. There is not earthly reason to prohibit it; the arguments made by opponents are silly and often contradictory. As I noted in the space earlier, Justice Scalia's dissent in the case was especially embarrassing. No one, for example, has a First Amendment right to refuse to interact with gay people in the public sphere. That's nonsense.

Also, I think the Supreme Court decision in Lawrence v. Texas is absolutely correct. Justice Kennedy's opinion is that case made precisely the right point when it said that

liberty presumes an autonomy of self that includes freedom of thought, belief, expression, and certain intimate conduct....  The petitioners are entitled to respect for their private lives. The State cannot demean their existence or control their destiny by making their private sexual conduct a crime. Their right to liberty under the Due Process Clause gives them the full right to engage in their conduct without intervention of the government.
To outlaw homosexual conduct is as much an invasion into basic liberty as it would be to outlaw heterosexual conduct as a whole. This kind of government intrusion is exactly the kind of this the 9th Amendment was written to prevent. 

Marriage, on the other hand, is not private. It is an explicitly public act, recognized (or not) by religious, social, or political communities. It's not conducted in private, and has no serious bearing on other protected behavior. One can be gay, straight or otherwise whether one is married or not. Although Justice Roberts dissent was unnecessarily uncivil, I think he was right. He said, in part,

Today the Court takes the extraordinary step of ordering every State to license and recognize same-sex marriage. Many people will rejoice at this decision, and I begrudge none their celebration. But for those who believe in a government of laws, not of men, the majority’s approach is deeply disheartening…
The majority’s decision is an act of will, not legal judgment. The right it announces has no basis in the Constitution or this Court’s precedent. The majority expressly disclaims judicial “caution” and omits even a pretense of humility, openly relying on its desire to remake society according to its own “new insight” into the “nature of injustice…

That is, the right to gay marriage is a legal one, to be protected by political process, not a constitutional one. I think Justice Kennedy and the four justices who signed his opinion went a step too far.



Monday, June 15, 2015

Effective Students = Effective Schools



If we are to achieve Thomas Jefferson's dream of an informed, independent polity, we need effective schools. Children need to acquire certain skills in order to function politically and economically in our society, and so adults need to hep them acquire such skills. Some people would like to think that home schooling is the best way to attain that goal, but they are being unrealistic at very least, and may even be wrong in their basic conclusions. If "society" needs young people to be educated, then "society" must do the educating, and that means we need schools.


One serious problem with this conclusion, however, is that bad schools are at least as harmful as no school at all. They may be physically dangerous, they may teach kids that life sucks because it is boring or arbitrary, and they may train people in destructive habits. As a result, we cannot just say we want schools; we want schools that teach effectively.
So, what makes an effective school?

The best answer -- and I do not mean this facetiously or cynically -- is that effective students make effective schools. In one sense, this statement is not very helpful. Students with the talent, discipline, and family support necessary to succeed don't need a lot of help from professional teachers. (Let's call this the First Premise of School Evaluation.) These kids will find a way to do well even despite bad teaching. If everybody in the school has to tools when he arrives, then the school looks, and maybe even is, a good school. Admission offices at selective private schools, like the one I work in, understand this fact, and seek applicants who will make the institution and the community stronger.

The less obvious sense of the statement is more important. Our goal is not to have effective schools, but to have effective students. The only reasonable measure of a school, therefore, is whether its graduates can so what they need to do when they leave. (This will be the Second Premise.) If a school's alumni, by and large, live happy and productive lives, then the school has met its ultimate purpose.

Of course, if we go back to the First Premise, though, we can't know whether the alumni's happiness and productivity came as a result of or despite the actions of the school. To evaluate the schools themselves. therefore, we need to find a way to measure the difference between the kid when he arrived and when he left.

This is a difficult thing to achieve, and will be the subject of a number of later posts.


Thursday, May 28, 2015

Should We Abolish Public Schools?

Calls to rely on private schooling fail to recognize the fundamental purpose of offering free, government-funded education.
Image result for ron paul
Ron Paul

As concerns about the quality of the American system of public education have grown, some have advocated abolishing it completely. The arguments for this proposal come from a number of angles, but they are all seriously misguided.

One approach is articulated by Libertarian Ron Paul. who sees the government involvement in education as the worst kind of meddling in the private lives of citizens. Only in schools, he seems to think, are kids exposed to drugs and pressures to conform. Schools, as they exist now, he thinks, only stunt our children's ability to think for themselves and forge an identity of their own.

The problem with this line of thinking is that it idealizes the alternatives. Does Paul imagine that all 1.1 million students in New York City public schools can be educated by their parents or the friends of their parents? And if they are, won't they be exposed to an even narrower point of view than in public schools? Does he figure that conformity comes only from the public sector?

Another is the "pure capitalist" or free market approach. By funding public schools, this line goes, we remove them from the pressures of the market, which would force them to meet the needs (or at least the desires) of parents. For-profit ventures -- or at least private ones -- would allow people to make freer choices, in the same way that markets allow more choice than centralized economies.

To an extent, this idea has some merit. It is the foundation of the independent school world's argument that state regulators should leave them alone. For example, the New York State Association of Independent Schools, to which my employer belongs, accredits its member institutions based on standards derived from the goals of the schools' own missions. In other words, the school is expected to announce what it intends, sell that product to families willing to pay between $25,000 and $50,000 a year, and then show how it delivers the product it sells. It mostly relies on the market to decide whether the product itself is worthy.

But the families in independent schools have leverage most people do not have. The very fact that they can pay such outrageously high tuition indicates the degree of social and economic leverage they already have. Not all families have that kind of negotiating power, and if they did they would not have the knowledge or experience necessary to apply it.

Not only that, but schooling provides a social good to people other than those directly involved in its purchase. The childless people in a school district, and those whose children have already passed through the schools, and whose children go to independent schools all benefit from a generally well-educated population. Employees who cannot read or reason or less effective; voters who cannot sort through the BS of a candidate's campaign may harm us all. Like roads, sewers, bridges, and other infrastructure, schools represent a societal investment in the functioning of the group. Free markets don't take such good into account.

Jefferson's vision for America included an informed, engaged electorate, and he assumed that such a thing required a certain level of education. He himself was a remarkable autodidact, who read voraciously and did more than dabble in everything from moral philosophy to botany. Jefferson certainly did not imagine that everyone would reach his levels of expertise in most things -- he was not an especially humble man -- but it seems that he did assume that anyone taught to read and count would then use those tools to expand their abilities more broadly. What he wanted, in the end, was a certain level of individual autonomy.

The question is how we can achieve that kind of autonomy for the greatest number of people.

Friday, May 22, 2015

"School Choice" and Public Subsidies

More than 200 years ago, Thomas Jefferson urged Americans to "educate and inform the whole mass of the people" because "they are the only sure reliance for the preservation of our liberty." The idea, not unique to him, is that popular governance depends on a literate voting public, conversant in the issues of the day and capable of making reasonable decisions in its own self-interest, whether that interest be collective or individual.

How exactly to get that done, however, has never been obvious. I doubt, for example, that Jefferson, who was a staunch defender of state power, would have supported federally mandated or federally funded schools. He did found the University of Virginia, a public institution, and he also supported the idea of very basic publicly-funded education for everyone. After three years of free schooling, though, Jefferson would have required students' families to pay for the rest.

New York governor Andrew Cuomo proposed earlier this month that the state provide tax breaks to help families fund private education. According to one source, "in New York City, 242,000 students attended nonpublic schools, 19 percent of the student population." Of those, many go to "elite," very expensive schools, like Packer Collegiate Institute in Brooklyn, Dalton in Manhattan, or Horace Mann in the Bronx. For most people, these school are far too expensive to contemplate, and it does not seem that Cuomo's proposal would provide enough money to pay all of the $30,000 tuitions involved.

The question is, then, whether Cuomo's idea would help further the project urged by Jefferson so long ago.  His motivation, he said, stemmed from the fact that “there are some areas, frankly, where the public schools are not places where you would want to send your children ... Sending your child to one of these failing public schools is in many ways condemning your child to get a second-class education.”   In that case, he figures, the state should support parents' efforts to get their kids out of bad schools and into better ones.

On its face, however, I don't see how this would help. Would more people find private schools available to them as a result of this tax break, or would the same wealthy, well-connected families simply double their benefits by saving the money required to insulate their children from the very masses Jefferson was most concerned about?

The teachers' unions are pretty sure it's the latter:  “We respect parents’ decisions to send their children to private or religious schools, but they shouldn’t ask taxpayers to subsidize those personal choices,” Mr. Korn said. “What’s next, tax credits for parents who want to golf at country clubs instead of municipal courses?”











http://ny.chalkbeat.org/2013/07/10/weiner-would-give-private-schools-equal-standing-at-city-doe/#.VV8hSShiF7N

Tuesday, September 16, 2014

Obama and Holder Get Weird

We're accustomed now to stories coming from China about government suppression of information. No one is surprised to hear that North Korea has arrested someone for speaking truth about what goes on over there. Totaltarian governments fear information because they hate to be embarrassed. Their legitimacy is so tenuous that any inkling of trouble could cause huge trouble down the line.

In the United States, however, we are supposed to trust that information will flow relatively freely. Sure, we'll hear about national security trumping clarity at times, but the 1st Amendment limits that kind of thing.

That's why the Attorney General's argument that a defamation lawsuit against a wholly private company is so bizarre. There really are only two options here, neither one of which is especially attractive. Either the company in question is in fact a front for a cover operation -- in which case the cover is blown just by the government's position -- or it is not -- in which case the Obama Administration has lost its bearings.

According to the New York Times, Holder's argument is classic double speak:
In this case, however, the Justice Department said that “the concerned federal agency, the particular information at issue and the bases for the assertion of the state-secrets privilege cannot be disclosed” without jeopardizing national security.

Why can't we sue? "Secret." Why is the information secret? "Secret." 

That's it.

But that cannot be it. Not here. Not ever.


Tuesday, September 9, 2014

Why the American Government is failing

The United States faces a number of challenges demanding government action. These problems are not unprecedented, but they are serious. ISIS looks a lot like Hitler to me; Ferguson looks a lot like Selma; the economy looks like has for most of US history outside the 30 years following World War II. Real people may suffer if we manage to ignore some or all of these things.

Yet the current federal government appears unable to respond in any meaningful way. Executive action is stymied by Congress and the courts not out of principle but out of dysfunction. It's not that Congress disagrees with any particular action, it disdains all action. It's not that the Supreme Court guards against abuse of power, it stands in the way of the narrow agenda of five people. President Obama, like President Bush, has not found a way to rally the necessary popular or political support to overcome these obstacles.

Francis Fukuyama, writing in Foreign Affairs makes a compelling case for the view that these failures are systemic and pervasive. The constitutional system designed 250 years ago may work in a general sense, but the way we are applying it right now will stymie or efforts at progress.

Francis Fukuyama
http://governanceproject.stanford.edu/people/fukuyama/

At bottom, Fukuyama argues that we have sucked all the flexibility out of our system. The combination of entrenched special interests (sugar producers, oil producers, unions) and populist resistance to technocracy has stifled the kind of innovation and dynamism that is supposed to be the hallmark of democratic systems. As Exhibit A he offers the US Forest Service, which used to be run by scientific experts insulated from pork barrel politics and narrow regulation by Congress. For a long time it made decisions -- some of them based on faulty information -- in the interest of the long-term good of the country. But soon the agency was eroded by the decay that Fukuyama says is inherent in any system, and the rational, fleet decision-making process bogged down in competing and even conflicting agendas.

The TEA Party is a the worst symptom of the problem, in my view, but it is not the cause.

As I have been saying for twenty years now, we are in the midst of a paradigm shift. These cause existential crisis because they reflect a change in the fundamental reality on which all our assumptions are based. We may be seeing the last decline of our particular form of liberal democracy.

Then again, we may not. If we as a group, as a society, can muster the energy and innovation necessary to see the change we need -- the kind of thing about which Americans have been most proud in their history, justifiably so -- we can transform rather than dissolve.

Now is the time, though. We need to get going.


Thursday, August 14, 2014

Are the Police in St. Louis Upholding the Law?

When a police officer in Ferguson, Missouri shot Michael Brown, he unwittingly unleashed a torrent of fury in the black community there. Brown was 18 years old and unarmed, and the because the police department divulged very little information about how the shooting occurred, except to say that Brown tried to grab the officer's weapon, his death remains one of those inexplicable cases in which a white cop has killed a black kid.

To compound the problem, the police have refused to release the name of the officer involved. So many death threats have been leveled against him that it's easy to see why the department would seek to shield him, but it reinforces the image of the police getting protection that Brown and others like him do not get.

It's also difficult to understand the highly militarized response of the police to protests. Images coming from the scene do not reinforce the idea that the police stand for law and order, but that they stand for violence and power. It is, of course, their job to prevent serious disruption of the city, but these are not the pictures anyone wants to see. High pressure hoses, noise cannons, tear gas and anti-riot tanks are the tools of dictators, and their use here does not serve the city of St. Louis or the people who live there.
St. Louis alderman says police dragged him from his car at Ferguson protest
St. Louis Post-Dispatch

When Fox News commentators condemn the police and defend protesters, you know something has gone over the top. 

Reporters from the Washington Post and The Huffington Post say they were arrested and then released without explanation. A St. Louis alderman was arrested and says he was dragged from his car. These things reflect a lack of discipline and training on the part of the police there, and do nothing to dispel the notion that Brown was probably killed without real justification.

Wednesday, July 23, 2014

NBC Should Dump Dungy -- He's a Distraction

Tony Dungy earned his fame as a football coach first, but since he retired from that job he has been treated as some kind of ethical guru by the meatheads at ESPN and the NFL Network. Dungy stood up for Michael Vick after Vick was convicted of running a dog fighting ring in which animals were brutally, viciously killed, and represented the early wave of black head coaches who had been denied equal treatment because of baseless assumptions about the connection between their ability and their color.

Now Dungy says that he would not have drafted Michael Sam, the SEC Defensive Player of the Year, because Sam came as gay before the draft and therefore would be "a distraction." To clear things up, Dungy said it was not Sam's homosexuality itself that would be a problem, but the "media attention" it would get.

Michael Sam 
(Francis Page Jr./Creative Commons) at http://www.neontommy.com/news/2014/02/why-do-you-care-if-michael-sam-gay

Media attention? 

The only reason the NFL exists is to get media attention. Tony Dungy's sole remaining employment relating to football is as a commentator on NBC. The NFL is, itself, nothing but a giant, expensive distraction. Every day is a "media circus" because the NFL makes all its money from television coverage.

If Dungy wants to avoid distractions, tell him to quit his job.

Tuesday, July 22, 2014

Putin, Law, and Truth

Vladimir Putin built his brutal Russian regime on lies. Like all dictators, Putin prefers to be see as a legitimate ruler, governing in the name of his subjects. Since that story cannot withstand even the briefest scrutiny, he must fabricate some information and obscure the rest. Control of all media outlets therefore lies at the heart of his power, because Russians must only receive news he selects or they would very quickly become angry and unmanageable.

The rest of the world is not under his thumb, however, and neither is empirical reality. This fundamental truth always proves to be the death of dictatorship and totalitarianism in the end. In the case of Malaysian Airlines Flight MH 17, Putin wants to maintain the fiction that he and his minions bear no responsibility for the deaths of hundreds of civilians flying 30,000 feet over the Ukrainian war zone, that any suggestion that they are at fault comes from a worldwide conspiracy to weaken Russia, and that the cause of truth and justice depends on Russia and its supporters. By many indications, Russian citizens, consuming Putin's own version of events, buy this narrative and continue to support Putin. But European and American citizens and their governments have access to the truth, and so demand that Putin behave more like a decent human being.

As a result, Putin is in trouble. As Stratfor analyst George Friedman writes, since the airplane was shot down "Putin then moves from being an effective, sophisticated ruler who ruthlessly uses power to being a dangerous incompetent supporting a hopeless insurrection with wholly inappropriate weapons. And the West, no matter how opposed some countries might be to a split with Putin, must come to grips with how effective and rational he really is." At some point, the real world intrudes on even the most tightly controlled places, and it has come rushing into Moscow in the last few days. we can only hope that it forces serious change in Russia relatively quickly.

Thursday, July 17, 2014

If Roberts' Approach is "Incremental" Maybe He is Real Judicial Conservative

Complaints outlined here, in a New York Times piece, suggest that "conservatives" on the Supreme Court want to overrule more precedents. The way the comments are accumulated overstates the trend a little, I think, but still, the remarks from Justices Alito, Scalia and Thomas indicate the distinction between true judicial conservatives and social conservatives.

Social conservatives want to avoid change in gender roles (by preventing abortions), race relations (by voiding affirmative action programs), and economic policy (by striking anything smelling of redistribution of wealth). They like the way things "back in the day."

Judicial conservatives want to avoid jarring the legal and constitutional framework under which we have been operating for some time. They avoid overturning previous rulings or substituting new priorities for older ones by allowing precedents to stand, even if they are controversial -- Roe v. Wade is the classic example.

I'm not crazy about Roberts's politics, but I dod appreciate that he is alt least somewhat hesitant to do what Scalia prefers, which is just make things the way he wants them.

Tuesday, July 15, 2014

The "Islamic State" is Neither

At the core of Muhammad's life was the quest for an all-in-one society, in which politics, religion, art, and economics all flow from one, central authority derived from the word of God. It is not anti-Muslim or anti-Islamic to say that Muhammad did not seek freedom of religion or pluralism; he believed he had found the answer, and he wanted to apply it.

For the "hyper-violent" adherents of the group called the Islamic State to call for such a thing, then, is deeply rooted in the traditions and philosophy of Islamic culture. Muhammad did the same, and he fought more than one serious, literal battle to achieve its creation. That he succeeded in doing so is one of the things that sets Islam apart from other world religions, and it infuses the faithful with a distinct, though not unique political mindset (one not at all different from that of most Israelis.)

But what would the government of such a group look like? For one, it would erase or diminish the lines drawn more-or-less arbitrarily by the Sykes-Picot Agreement of the early years of the last century. It would be exclusively Sunni, as Iran is fully aware, and authoritarian at least. It would not be open to diversity, and it would not be an especially willing partner with the United States in maintaining Western interests.

So far, IS has spent all its time rebelling against the status quo, and so has not established anything like a state as yet. It governs nothing, eve as it expands the reach of its military domination and intimidation. Most commentators assume that it will be takfiri and brutal. Al Qaeda itself has disavowed many of its methods as too nasty, and while that group has ulterior motives for such remarks, it's still saying a lot that Zawahiri flinches at their violence.

http://www.eiilir.eu/
If these rebels act anything like takfiris elsewhere, they are not leading in the tradition of Islam. Muslim tradition allows excommunications and attacks on apostates, but Muhammad was a statesman as well as a profit, and he impose strict rules of evidence and procedure on such practices. Here is the Q'uran itself:

O you who believe! When you go (to fight) in the Cause of God, verify (the truth), and say not to anyone who greets you (by embracing Islam): "You are not a believer"; seeking the perishable goods of the worldly life. There are much more profits and booties with God. Even as he is now, so were you yourselves before till God conferred on you His Favours (i.e. guided you to Islam), therefore, be cautious in discrimination. God is Ever Well-Acquainted with what you do. (4:94)

That is, one can not simply wander around the desert killing people on his own initiative, as these people have done. Until they prove themselves to be true Muslims, then, they will gain no legitimacy, and no statehood.



Friday, July 11, 2014

The Fundamental and Dangerous Problem with the Hobby Lobby Decision

A disingenuous claim, at best (www.rightspeak.net)

I have two problems with the recent ruling in Hobby Lobby v. Sebelius. One, as I have already tried to make clear, has to do with the intellectual inconsistency of a few justices, led by Antonin Scalia. When justices are inconsistent or dishonest about their reasoning it undermines the political discourse in this country and leads us further away from effective self-governance.

The real danger of the opinion, however, lies in its subversion of the very foundation of democratic government: the acceptance that sometimes you don't get your way. Claiming a 1st Amendment exemption from health care laws is disingenuous. Denial of health care coverage for birth control is not a religious practice, and it does not even stem from a serious religious belief. Rather, it's an expression of a political preference, and the owners of the big box hobby store are bitter that their side lost the political debate.

If representative government is going to work, everyone needs to accept the fact that he cannot always have things his way. Our Bill of Rights was not constructed to guarantee that we never lose a debate. To water down fundamental rights -- or, rather, to use the word "right" inappropriately -- is to weaken the whole scheme and threaten our ability to function as a political society.