SCOTUSblog » Academic Round-up

Saturday, April 20, 2013

"Guns Don't Kill People, Immigrants Kill People"

Chuck Grassley wants us to be safe. To prevent the kind of behavior that led to the Boston Marathon bombings, he wants to change the way we regulate immigration. Speaking before the Senate Judiciary Committee this week, Senator Grassley wondered
How can individuals evade authorities and plan such attacks on our soil?How can we beef up security checks on people who wish to enter the U.S.? How do we ensure that people who wish to do us harm are not eligible for benefits under the immigration laws, including this new bill before us?

What we know now is that one of the suspected bombers was a nineteen-year-old who graduated from Cambridge Rindge and Latin, a remarkably successful public school. He was a college kid who tweeted about doing laundry. Grassley may not have been able to know these details when he made his comments, but that's no excuse for the silliness of his message.


The speech is silly because just before he delivered it, he helped kill the Obama Administration's proposed gun-control bill. Why? Because it would have made owning and trading assault rifles more difficult for "law abiding citizens."

Of course Dzhokar Tsarnaev was a law-abiding citizen right up to the moment when he filled a backpack with explosives, walked to Copley Square, and detonated a bomb that killed an eight-year-old boy, among others. And the police officers he killed did not die from the explosions. They died because Tsanaev and his brother had guns and ammunition designed to kill people.

Grassley and his ilk cannot have it both ways. If they support the 2nd Amendment, they must face the fact that, if the right to own guns is a fundamental right it is so because the founders wanted to permit occasionally violent dissent against the government. Place the 2nd Amendment between the 1st and the 3rd and take the group as seriously as Grassley and that whack-job Wayne LaPierre want to do, and you get armed opposition to the government.

Like the Tsarnaevs.



No comments: